View Single Post
  #231  
Old 05-26-2010, 08:46 PM
Noah-Tall Noah-Tall is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Red Deer
Posts: 29
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by TreeGuy View Post
Well, after reading all eight pages, I must conclude......

Holes cause death, not energy transfer. My three blade 100gr Thunderhead kills stuff just as dead as any centerfire out there applying far less energy. Why? The surface area of my wound channel is huge. My mulie this year was shot through the heart, stumbled 15 yards and was dead within 20 seconds. To paraphrase a certain politician, 'It's the HOLE stupid!'.
I'll have to politely disagree. You need energy to get the arrow to the animal. And then you need more energy to get the arrow to penetrate, which is a transfer of energy. I would doubt that your arrow would kill as good as a centerfire if your quarry was 400 yards away. Unless you had enough energy to get the arrow to the target and penetrate. Holes kill, but you need the energy to make the hole.
So, after 8 pages of nonsense, you need both to kill an animal.