First off, you're comparing (fairly large) midsize suvs (MDX, telluride) to compact suv's. Decide what size you want, and compare apples to apples.
Next, go test drive them all and decide for yourself.
Aside from the kia (which is an unknown), they all are reliable, and all stand up to the same crash tests.
If it was me (and using the cars on your list)..
New RAV4 Trail, no question.
|