Alberta Outdoorsmen Forum

Alberta Outdoorsmen Forum (http://www.outdoorsmenforum.ca/index.php)
-   Hunting Discussion (http://www.outdoorsmenforum.ca/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   Make it Mandatory (http://www.outdoorsmenforum.ca/showthread.php?t=430207)

birdseye 03-22-2024 11:11 PM

Make it Mandatory
 
After watching the hunting chanel for a bit,I say its time for the sponsors EG=Sako,Ruger,Savage,Weatherby,Nosler,Hornady,Fede ral,to make the hunters they sponsor profesional marksmen,as in hit certain targets at certain ranges to obtain and or keep the sponsor.They all claim to sell the best products,and most of the shows shooters are less then average to bad.3"-4" group is horrible and i have seen so many of them brag up this kinda accuracy.I think making the hunters applying for or keeping there sponsors should be certified marksmen.Wouldnt this be better for all hunters overvall and the name we all carry.Sorry if this is not written the best,kinda pee'd off and rattled at what i witnessed on a wild chanel program.

Pathfinder76 03-23-2024 07:35 AM

I like more rules too. I wish they would just take everyone’s guns away.

Smoky buck 03-23-2024 08:11 AM

I don’t care about what distance someone is comfortable shooting or if they are touching bullets doing so

What matters is the know their limits, they make ethical choices on shot selection, and they focus on making clean shots. Don’t care if the hunter is banging everything at under 20yards or is a sniper at 500yards

More times than not it’s nothing to do with ones ability with the weapon at the range but instead poor shot selection in the field. It’s usually nothing to do with distance but instead rushing a shot or poor shot angles

As long as they make realistic ethical choices I am fine with that. I have met plenty of hunters who can punch paper like a champ but suck at making good choices in the field or can’t control buck fever

obsessed1 03-23-2024 08:25 AM

I think everyone should pass a shooting test before they can buy a hunting tag. If you cant hold sub moa at 100 or moa at 400 no tag for you!

Lets just rule this sport to death.

Dick284 03-23-2024 08:50 AM

I think we should have a rule that if you want to rant or gripe, on the forum you should know how to compose a proper sentence and use punctuation and capital letters in the correct place. Maybe we should have a breathalyzer attached to our internet keyboards as well.

The road to hell is paved with good intentions, I believe is the proper saying here………

The sarcasm light has been lit……….

oldgutpile 03-23-2024 09:05 AM

outside factors
 
Fine and dandy to shoot at paper and achieve bullets touching, but add adrenalin (aka buck fever in some!), or try making the same shot after a 200 yard uphill dash. Attempting to put all the dots in a row to catch it on camera complicates matters even worse.
Know your rifle and know your limits.

Bushrat 03-23-2024 09:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by obsessed1 (Post 4711292)
I think everyone should pass a shooting test before they can buy a hunting tag. If you cant hold sub moa at 100 or moa at 400 no tag for you!

Well that would get rid of at least 75% of hunters if they were shooting off a bench, if they are shooting offhand it would be pretty much 100%. Heard lots of guys say crap like that then they can't do it themselves.

How about we test you?

CBintheNorth 03-23-2024 09:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bushrat (Post 4711306)
Well that would get rid of at least 75% of hunters if they were shooting off a bench, if they are shooting offhand it would be pretty much 100%. Heard lots of guys say crap like that then they can't do it themselves.

How about we test you?

I believe his comment was being made sarcastically.

catnthehat 03-23-2024 09:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by obsessed1 (Post 4711292)
I think everyone should pass a shooting test before they can buy a hunting tag. If you cant hold sub moa at 100 or moa at 400 no tag for you!

Lets just rule this sport to death.

Here is the field test for a moose license in Sweden.
There is also a test for a shotgun license.
Cat
Precision Shooting
In precision shooting, the sampler’s ability to shoot two tight match pictures of four shots
each is examined. The first shooting series the sampler will shoot from a shooting bench
with good support and the other series is shot knee standing or sitting down. Shooting
distance should be 80 meters.
To pass requires the bullet holes in each series are fully covered by a circular result image
templates.
Series shot from shooting bench may have up to 12 cm spread.
Series shot knee standing or sitting down may have at most 17 cm spread.
If only one series is approved, the test is failed.
Practical big game rifle test
The practical big game rifle includes -
1. Shooting at a stationary moosefigure/target
2.Shooting at running moosefigure/target
Shooting distance is 80 meters.
At the time of the test the sampler may shoot a maximum of 9 series. One series consist of
4 shots, 2 shots at stationary and 2 shots at running target. For series to be approved, all 4
shots should be placed in the result field on the moosefigure/target.
Of these 9 series, at least 3 series must be approved for the test to be approved.

Dmay 03-23-2024 09:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dick284 (Post 4711297)
I think we should have a rule that if you want to rant or gripe, on the forum you should know how to compose a proper sentence and use punctuation and capital letters in the correct place.

This!!! First and foremost.

Bushleague 03-23-2024 09:30 AM

My own talents lie in hitting the front half of a deer real fast at 40 yards, more deliberation is generally required to miss things that I DONT want to hit, than actually putting a bullet in the boiler room...

To be fair though, If I owned Sako or Vortex I wouldn't sponsor me.

pikergolf 03-23-2024 09:31 AM

Folks tie success to their egos, that's why so many poor choices are made in the field. For a a few hunters it is just shooting their winter game, that is a whole lot less pressure.

Smoky buck 03-23-2024 09:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by catnthehat (Post 4711313)
Here is the field test for a moose license in Sweden.
There is also a test for a shotgun license.
Cat
Precision Shooting
In precision shooting, the sampler’s ability to shoot two tight match pictures of four shots
each is examined. The first shooting series the sampler will shoot from a shooting bench
with good support and the other series is shot knee standing or sitting down. Shooting
distance should be 80 meters.
To pass requires the bullet holes in each series are fully covered by a circular result image
templates.
Series shot from shooting bench may have up to 12 cm spread.
Series shot knee standing or sitting down may have at most 17 cm spread.
If only one series is approved, the test is failed.
Practical big game rifle test
The practical big game rifle includes -
1. Shooting at a stationary moosefigure/target
2.Shooting at running moosefigure/target
Shooting distance is 80 meters.
At the time of the test the sampler may shoot a maximum of 9 series. One series consist of
4 shots, 2 shots at stationary and 2 shots at running target. For series to be approved, all 4
shots should be placed in the result field on the moosefigure/target.
Of these 9 series, at least 3 series must be approved for the test to be approved.

Many North American shooters would fail the moving target part of the course. Europeans definitely focus more training on moving targets than most here do.

The guys doing the driven boar hunts are actually very impressive to watch pick of running boar with clean shots minamal misses

Bushleague 03-23-2024 09:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smoky buck (Post 4711319)
Many North American shooters would fail the moving target part of the course. Europeans definitely focus more training on moving targets than most here do.

The guys doing the driven boar hunts are actually very impressive to watch pick of running boar with clean shots minamal misses

Worth mentioning, Sweden had mandatory military service at least into the early 90's IIRC... that in itself would raise the standard quite a bit.

catnthehat 03-23-2024 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smoky buck (Post 4711319)
Many North American shooters would fail the moving target part of the course. Europeans definitely focus more training on moving targets than most here do.

The guys doing the driven boar hunts are actually very impressive to watch pick of running boar with clean shots minamal misses

A friend of mine lives in Sweden, hunting there is a very big privilege and not cheap, IIRC there is a two year apprenticeship under a liscen4d hunter before you can go out on your own, as well.
Most people could not afford to hunt there, and they are only allowed to own a certain number of firearms, hence the number of combination guns and drilling over there.
Cat

Smoky buck 03-23-2024 09:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bushleague (Post 4711316)
My own talents lie in hitting the front half of a deer real fast at 40 yards, more skill is generally put into NOT hitting sticks than getting the bullet into the boiler room...

Then again, theres a pretty good reason even the most famous bush hunters never got sponsored by Vortex or Sako.

Yup fast shooting, small window, shooting from awkward positions, tough angles and often deer that are walking not completely stationary at close range is the name of the game with most of my hunts. Outside of my antelope(325yards) last year every animal has been under 40yards in the last 7years. Most are taken at 30yards or less

Totally different challenges and set of skills. The ability to break down tough shot angles quickly is a big one for this style of hunting in my opinion

Smoky buck 03-23-2024 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bushleague (Post 4711321)
Worth mentioning, Sweden had mandatory military service at least into the early 90's IIRC... that in itself would raise the standard quite a bit.

I know a few military guys family included that I would not call good shots lol

Sweden military might be different though

Smoky buck 03-23-2024 09:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by catnthehat (Post 4711322)
A friend of mine lives in Sweden, hunting there is a very big privilege and not cheap, IIRC there is a two year apprenticeship under a liscen4d hunter before you can go out on your own, as well.
Most people could not afford to hunt there, and they are only allowed to own a certain number of firearms, hence the number of combination guns and drilling over there.
Cat

Totally different world

I think it would be good if hunter Ed had more hands on training but I don’t know if going to the extreme of some European countries would be beneficial

Bushleague 03-23-2024 09:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smoky buck (Post 4711324)
Yup fast shooting, small window, shooting from awkward positions, tough angles and often deer that are walking not completely stationary at close range is the name of the game with most of my hunts. Outside of my antelope(325yards) last year every animal has been under 40yards in the last 7years. Most are taken at 30yards or less

Totally different challenges and set of skills. The ability to break down tough shot angles quickly is a big one for this style of hunting in my opinion

My cousin only hunts agricultural areas, and routinely makes shots at distances that I personally would not even consider... the few times he's hunted bush with me his shooting skills (as well as his nerve and sense of direction) have not been up to the challenge.

For some types of hunting sub MOA groups off the bench are somewhat relevant, for other types of hunting not so much.

Rusty50 03-23-2024 09:57 AM

Practice, practice, and more practice. Same as any sport, if you want to be at the top of your game send a lot of lead downrange.

elkhunter11 03-23-2024 10:16 AM

I am against more restrictions , that being said, I have my own standards for taking new people out hunting. I don't let new shooters shoot past 200 yards, and I like to see them shoot first. When new shooters wanted to hunt waterfowl with us, I set a restriction that they have to come out to skeet and break more than 50% of the targets first.

58thecat 03-23-2024 10:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rusty50 (Post 4711331)
Practice, practice, and more practice. Same as any sport, if you want to be at the top of your game send a lot of lead downrange.


Exactly.[emoji106]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

huntinstuff 03-23-2024 10:19 AM

Know your limits.

Mine is 300m with a rifle. 40m with a bow.

Im ok with that. I have no desire personally to shoot further.

Those that do I say rock on. Shooting is a great hobby. I fully support it in all ways and styles.

I've been part of the "sponsor gear" users. Leupold, Primos, etc. Good gear. Not a lot of "junk" out there, but you take all their chatter with a grain of salt.

Smoky buck 03-23-2024 10:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bushleague (Post 4711330)
My cousin only hunts agricultural areas, and routinely makes shots at distances that I personally would not even consider... the few times he's hunted bush with me his shooting skills (as well as his nerve and sense of direction) have not been up to the challenge.

For some types of hunting sub MOA groups off the bench are somewhat relevant, for other types of hunting not so much.

Yup totally different conditions demanding different skill set

I too have taken a few guys out bush hunting and I hear situations that they had where they couldn’t get a shot because of xyz. Now put myself in that situation and I commonly take animals under those conditions. Put me in open country longer shots I will pass on opportunities that person will do without a second thought

Smoky buck 03-23-2024 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by huntinstuff (Post 4711339)
Know your limits.

Mine is 300m with a rifle. 40m with a bow.

Im ok with that. I have no desire personally to shoot further.

Those that do I say rock on. Shooting is a great hobby. I fully support it in all ways and styles.

I've been part of the "sponsor gear" users. Leupold, Primos, etc. Good gear. Not a lot of "junk" out there, but you take all their chatter with a grain of salt.

Sounds about right to me

huntinstuff 03-23-2024 10:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smoky buck (Post 4711345)
Yup totally different conditions demanding different skill set

I too have taken a few guys out bush hunting and I hear situations that they had where they couldn’t get a shot because of xyz. Now put myself in that situation and I commonly take animals under those conditions. Put me in open country longer shots I will pass on opportunities that person will do without a second thought

Exactly. I turn down 400 and 500m shots that my boys do without issue. But I smirk because.the ammo they shoot is made by me....lol

Ackleyman 03-23-2024 10:41 AM

[QUOTE=birdseye;4711267]After watching the hunting chanel for a bit,I say its time for the sponsors EG=Sako,Ruger,Savage,Weatherby,Nosler,Hornady,Fede ral,to make the hunters they sponsor profesional marksmen,as in hit certain targets at certain ranges to obtain and or keep the sponsor.They all claim to sell the best products,and most of the shows shooters are less then average to bad.3"-4" group is horrible and i have seen so many of them brag up this kinda accuracy.I think making the hunters applying for or keeping there sponsors should be certified marksmen.Wouldnt this be better for all hunters overvall and the name we all carry.

Did they mention how far they were shooting with these "horrible groups" ?
Most strive for tighter groups but if you can shoot a 3" group with the rifle and scope you can afford good on yuh. Deer , let alone Elk and Moose are a big target , excluding the ocassional long shot , Ive seen the majority of WT killed while hunting with buddies at less then 200yds.....lot of the time less then 100.
More rules in the shooting sports are like getting a root canal

CanuckShooter 03-23-2024 10:45 AM

I get a kick out of watching them playing with knobs on their scopes while the game walks away, imagine not taking the shot because you don't have your 'cheat sheet'. Sometimes the new tech does you no favours.

Smoky buck 03-23-2024 11:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CanuckShooter (Post 4711354)
I get a kick out of watching them playing with knobs on their scopes while the game walks away, imagine not taking the shot because you don't have your 'cheat sheet'. Sometimes the new tech does you no favours.

Yeah I bought a scope with a turret by accident not paying attention. I think it might go up for sale as I have no use for that feature

Smokinyotes 03-23-2024 11:18 AM

I don’t care how others shoot. I only worry about myself. Just a question though, why would you watch “Wild” tv?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:24 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.