Alberta Outdoorsmen Forum

Alberta Outdoorsmen Forum (http://www.outdoorsmenforum.ca/index.php)
-   Hunting Discussion (http://www.outdoorsmenforum.ca/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   Best Skinning knife for $200 (http://www.outdoorsmenforum.ca/showthread.php?t=406955)

Coiloil37 02-18-2024 02:11 PM

My most used knife is my spyderco waterway. This thing has lived on my bait board for five years and sees constant, hard use.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...1aeb7868ce.png


The last time I took my decky fishing he was on a marlin, moved laterally from left to right and hit the hilt of the knife that was sticking out of the bait board snapping it off

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...2c14308b02.jpg


https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...76ac5a18fe.jpg


It was like the loss of my left hand. I haven’t seen one of these for sale in the past four years and they’ve been discontinued. Hence the reason it was the LAST time I took my mate on the boat.

So I did what anyone would do and TIG welded it back together. Unfortunately the heat vaporised some of the apex although it now lives to cut again.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...1188f8a853.jpg



Then I scoured the web and found that warriors and wonders (blades Canada) had stock so I had two brought over the other day restoring the harmony on my boat.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...dc59e82b2e.jpg


Bit of wear over the past five years. Difficult to see if they’re not held over each other but I’ve worn it down about 1/8” along the edge.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...9b88c861b4.jpg


Best saltwater boat knife I’ve run across and a pity they discontinued it. Now I will reprofile the old blade to blend that gouge out and smooth up the edge. It too will see boat duty again.

Phil McCracken 02-25-2024 05:27 AM

Pretty quiet here lately, so I figured I would share this.

Latest one I just finished yesterday. It is a drop point with a blade approximately 3 1/2" long. CPM Magnacut stainless steel with an HRC of 63.

Handle is burlap brown Micarta, with G10 neon green liners. Brass pins. Comes with an olive green Kydex sheath.

Will be posted on Buy and Sell soon...:)


https://i.imgur.com/t9rB020.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/bVaXUI4.jpg

leeelmer 02-28-2024 06:42 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Clint just finished these up for me
Super pumped

MountainTi 02-28-2024 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phil McCracken (Post 4704230)
Pretty quiet here lately, so I figured I would share this.

Latest one I just finished yesterday. It is a drop point with a blade approximately 3 1/2" long. CPM Magnacut stainless steel with an HRC of 63.

Handle is burlap brown Micarta, with G10 neon green liners. Brass pins. Comes with an olive green Kydex sheath.

Will be posted on Buy and Sell soon...:)


https://i.imgur.com/t9rB020.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/bVaXUI4.jpg

That's a beauty of a knife Phil!

ORVIS 02-28-2024 07:44 PM

I got an Outdoor Edge Knife with replaceable blades and so far it has been my go to knife. Just make sure it gets taken apart and wash thoroughly after use.

badbrass 03-04-2024 05:51 PM

Ya they are ok! But when you use a custom new knife, you know what’s in your hand! Like you said, and they are always sharp,
but you have to clean the real good! Which we always do! But when you learn to sharpen your knife the correct way! I will always use my custom knife! Each to their own!


But Outdoor Edge Knife with replaceable blades and so far it has been my go to knife. Just make sure it gets taken apart and wash thoroughly after use.[/QUOTE]

Sundog57 03-05-2024 08:04 AM

This thread has been really interesting and has showcased some really impressive craftsmanship.
I have no doubt that a perfectly honed Magnacut blade will outperform almost anything else but...
Being a practical guy (and kinda cheap) I carry three knives whenever I am hunting big game.
A Fieldcraft "Zip Knife" - makes opening up the animal REALLY easy
A Fieldcraft "Razor Knife" - replaceable blades - what's not to like and yess you have to really pay attention to getting it clean afterward
A Grohmann 103 - the best designed general purpose big game knife I have come across to date.

I have done many deer and a couple of moose with this combination
No complaints and all for less than $200 as the original title suggests
and if I lose one, it won't be a one of a kind irreplaceable.

SuperCub 03-05-2024 08:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sundog57 (Post 4706898)
A Grohmann 103 - the best designed general purpose big game knife I have come across to date.

No flame here, but I see the #1 Russell belt knife as a better "general purpose BG knife". The smaller size and drop point make it better for dressing game while the elliptical shape blade make it a very good choice to skinning.

The old carbon one in the middle is mine. I found it in a pawn shop for $20 out the door. The one on the top is a Bark River CDN that I had reshaped to approximate the smaller #1. It might be a bit better for larger (than deer) game.

https://i.imgur.com/Ju1m14rl.jpg

eaglemountainman 03-07-2024 05:29 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Grohmann #1
Bottom blade

Dom4 03-07-2024 08:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by eaglemountainman (Post 4707311)
Grohmann #1
Bottom blade


Those handles look awesome on those knives.

Dom4 03-11-2024 08:08 AM

Hey Guys,

I should have taken some photos but it completely slipped my mind while I was doing it. I had some walleye to fillet yesterday and instead of grabbing my Fillet knife I grabbed the Benchmade Meatcrafter I have because I was wondering how it would work on fish...

My point here being is that just because something isn't labeled a Fillet knife it could still do a wicked job on fish if the shape of the blade is correct. If anyone else has one kicking around and you like to fish I would recomend you trying it becasue I had a very pleasant suprise when I did.

Phil McCracken 03-12-2024 10:01 AM

This is my own gutting knife design, which I have recently completed. Made a few of these in the past.

The commercial version has a concave curve at the cutting edge. Although it works well, it is challenging to properly sharpen as you cannot use a flat stone. One can only use a round sharpening tool, which is difficult to maintain an adequate bevel. My design has a straight edge, making it easy to sharpen.

This one is made out of 1084 High Carbon Steel. It has been heat treated/tempered at HRC 61-62. Edge sharpened at 20 degrees.

The handle is made out of "Buckskin" Dymalux , brown, beige, and grey in color. Copper pins to finish it.

This one will be in the Buy and Sell section soon...:)

https://i.imgur.com/u04bmWO.jpg

badbrass 03-12-2024 08:06 PM

Looks great!





Quote:

Originally Posted by Phil McCracken (Post 4708581)
This is my own gutting knife design, which I have recently completed. Made a few of these in the past.

The commercial version has a concave curve at the cutting edge. Although it works well, it is challenging to properly sharpen as you cannot use a flat stone. One can only use a round sharpening tool, which is difficult to maintain an adequate bevel. My design has a straight edge, making it easy to sharpen.

This one is made out of 1084 High Carbon Steel. It has been heat treated/tempered at HRC 61-62. Edge sharpened at 20 degrees.

The handle is made out of "Buckskin" Dymalux , brown, beige, and grey in color. Copper pins to finish it.

This one will be in the Buy and Sell section soon...:)

https://i.imgur.com/u04bmWO.jpg


1899b 03-12-2024 09:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phil McCracken (Post 4708581)
This is my own gutting knife design, which I have recently completed. Made a few of these in the past.

The commercial version has a concave curve at the cutting edge. Although it works well, it is challenging to properly sharpen as you cannot use a flat stone. One can only use a round sharpening tool, which is difficult to maintain an adequate bevel. My design has a straight edge, making it easy to sharpen.

This one is made out of 1084 High Carbon Steel. It has been heat treated/tempered at HRC 61-62. Edge sharpened at 20 degrees.

The handle is made out of "Buckskin" Dymalux , brown, beige, and grey in color. Copper pins to finish it.

This one will be in the Buy and Sell section soon...:)

https://i.imgur.com/u04bmWO.jpg

Absolute art….

Dom4 03-13-2024 08:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phil McCracken (Post 4708581)
This is my own gutting knife design, which I have recently completed. Made a few of these in the past.

The commercial version has a concave curve at the cutting edge. Although it works well, it is challenging to properly sharpen as you cannot use a flat stone. One can only use a round sharpening tool, which is difficult to maintain an adequate bevel. My design has a straight edge, making it easy to sharpen.

This one is made out of 1084 High Carbon Steel. It has been heat treated/tempered at HRC 61-62. Edge sharpened at 20 degrees.

The handle is made out of "Buckskin" Dymalux , brown, beige, and grey in color. Copper pins to finish it.

This one will be in the Buy and Sell section soon...:)

https://i.imgur.com/u04bmWO.jpg

Someone will be lucky to get this one Phil.

badbrass 03-27-2024 02:24 PM

New Knives!
 
From our own Phil McCracken. First one, a Paring Knife was made for my wife!
Metal: 52100 High Carbon Steel, HRC 59 and is super sharp!
Handle: White Juma
Stainless steel pins'
Sharpened @ 15 degrees

My knife is: A Drop Point
CMP Magnacut sharpened @ 17 degrees
HRC 63
Handle: Burlap ( brown) Micarta
Neon Green G10 Liners
With brsss pins.
Kydex Sheath
Man, both of these knives are super sharp. and very well made! he posted a picture of the knife I wanted. But he said it sold 5 days prior! Asked if he could make me one in the picture? And he said yes! Thanks Again Phil!
https://i.imgur.com/oSXaYxh.jpg

DirtShooter 03-28-2024 09:25 AM

Those are real nice

Stubb 03-28-2024 09:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DirtShooter (Post 4712577)
Those are real nice

X2 really like both! nice work

sns2 03-28-2024 10:17 AM

Nice score, bad brass.

sns2 03-28-2024 10:24 AM

At the beginning of this thread there was a lot of talk about Grohmann. Interestingly, I saw on Clint Chisan’s Instagram page a set of Magnacut skinning knives for a moose guide based on the Grohmann #1 design. Thought I’d post the pic. If I didn’t have two of his knives in the past year, I’d be getting in line for one of these.


https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...6add203777.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

badbrass 03-28-2024 10:52 AM

They look great! We went out East, and was going to the Grohmann plant in Pictou, Nova Scotia! But with covid, they did not have any workers a year latter to give a walk through the plant! Was looking forward to that! Next time!


Quote:

Originally Posted by sns2 (Post 4712611)
At the beginning of this thread there was a lot of talk about Grohmann. Interestingly, I saw on Clint Chisan’s Instagram page a set of Magnacut skinning knives for a moose guide based on the Grohmann #1 design. Thought I’d post the pic.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...6add203777.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Phil McCracken 04-01-2024 05:59 AM

Just completed this drop point for someone.

The metal is 80CRV2 High Carbon Steel. The cutting edge is approximately 4" long, made from 1/8" stock. OAL is about 8". It has been heat treated to HRC61. Sharpened at 20 degrees.

Green canvas Micarta handles, with G10 orange spacers. The pins are brown Micarta. And of course a Kydex sheath is included.


https://i.imgur.com/dx35BIQ.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/UMnEXlk.jpg

fishnguy 04-29-2024 01:45 AM

Good price ($160): https://www.bladescanada.com/Benchma...006?cPath=569&

Also good price ($269): https://www.bladescanada.com/Benchma...202?cPath=569&

Shipping is $10, if I recall correctly.

sns2 04-29-2024 08:15 PM

4 Attachment(s)
My buddy Prinny53 had Clint Chisan do him up a Magnacut fileting knife for him. Turned out really nice.

Attachment 190102
Attachment 190103
Attachment 190104
Attachment 190105


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Demonical 04-29-2024 08:18 PM

70 pages... wow

prinny53 04-30-2024 07:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sns2 (Post 4720383)
My buddy Prinny53 had Clint Chisan do him up a Magnacut fileting knife for him. Turned out really nice.

Attachment 190102
Attachment 190103
Attachment 190104
Attachment 190105


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I can not wait to get this knife. Clint was super easy to deal with and willing to accommodate all my little requests to customize this knife. This will be my second knife from Clint with likely a few more down the road.

Pathfinder76 04-30-2024 07:14 AM

A Dan Crotts Semi Skinner at work again.

https://i.imgur.com/KN4ntxZ.jpg

badbrass 04-30-2024 11:38 AM

Good for you! Congrats!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pathfinder76 (Post 4720478)
A Dan Crotts Semi Skinner at work again.

https://i.imgur.com/KN4ntxZ.jpg


Pathfinder76 04-30-2024 12:16 PM

I broke my back at some point in my life so it’s becoming more of a chore to get stuff like this done. Lol.

saskwhitey 04-30-2024 02:57 PM

Nice work Chuck


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:04 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.